Rekey or Replace Your Locks: Which Do You Need?
Rekey a working lock when you need its old keys to stop working; replace a lock that is damaged, worn, or no longer suits your needs. Call (754) 342-6282 for mobile lock rekeying—we come to you.

Need help now? (754) 342-6282
Rekey or Replace Locks Based on the Problem
Rekeying changes the lock cylinder so the old keys no longer operate it; the lock hardware stays in place. Replacing changes the lock itself, which may make sense when the existing lock is damaged or you want a different type of lock.
Choose rekeying for a key-control problem
The key turns the lock and the hardware works, but you do not know who has copies or you want one key to operate compatible locks. A locksmith checks whether the lock can be rekeyed before changing its internal keying.
Choose replacement for a hardware problem
A cracked, badly worn, or unreliable lock may need new hardware rather than a new key pattern. Replacement is also the option when you want a different lock style or feature.
Separate door trouble from key trouble
A deadbolt that binds only when the door is shut may be rubbing against the strike plate, not failing because of its key. Note whether the lock works with the door open; that observation helps identify whether the lock or the door alignment needs attention.
Check These Signs Before You Decide on a Lock
Look at each entry door and consider both the lock’s condition and who may still have a key. One worn lock does not necessarily mean every lock in the home needs replacement.
- The lock works, but keys may be out of your control — Rekeying can make existing copies stop working without replacing the lock hardware. This can apply after a key goes missing or when you are unsure who kept a copy.
- The key sticks or the lock is unreliable — Do not force a key that catches, bends, or will not turn consistently. A locksmith can inspect the key and lock to determine whether rekeying will solve the issue or the hardware needs repair or replacement.
- You want different hardware — If your goal is a different lock design or feature, rekeying alone will not provide it. Ask about replacement and have the new hardware checked against the door.
- You rent your home — Check with the property manager before arranging a lock change or rekey. Confirm which doors and locks they want included so the work does not affect shared or managed access.
Use These Steps to Choose Rekeying or Replacement
A quick, orderly check gives a locksmith useful information without taking apart the lock. Do not force a key or remove lock hardware to diagnose a problem.
- List the doors and locks — Write down which exterior doors have a deadbolt, a doorknob lock, or both. Note any other locks you want addressed so each one can be checked.
- Gather the keys you still have — Set aside the keys that currently work and mark which lock each key fits. Note any missing keys or people who may still have copies.
- Test each lock with its key — Operate the key gently with the door open, then observe whether the deadbolt or latch moves smoothly. Stop if the key catches or resists instead of turning normally.
- Check the lock with the door open and closed — If the lock moves freely with the door open but binds when closed, mention that detail. It can point to contact between the bolt and the strike plate rather than a key-control issue.
- Look over the visible hardware — Check the lock, handle, and strike plate for obvious damage or looseness. Do not take out the lock cylinder; a loose or damaged part may call for repair or replacement, not simply rekeying.
- Match the choice to your goal — Choose rekeying when the hardware works and the main concern is who can use existing keys. Consider replacement when the lock is damaged or you want different hardware.
- Tell the locksmith what you found — Describe the door, the type of lock, whether you have a working key, and what happens when you test it. Our lock rekeying service starts with checking the lock and your rekeying need.
- Test the finished lock — After the work, check the new key with the door open first, then with it closed. Confirm that the deadbolt or latch moves fully and that the old key no longer operates a rekeyed lock.
Need help now? (754) 342-6282
What a Locksmith Changes During a Rekey
A rekey changes the lock cylinder’s keying so a different key operates the lock. It does not replace the outside lock hardware, and it does not fix a damaged cylinder, a sticking door, or a bolt that is blocked by the frame.
A locksmith checks the lock type and condition, then determines whether its cylinder can be rekeyed. If the lock is damaged or incompatible with the requested work, replacement may be the practical next step. Ask which locks will be changed and which keys will operate them when the job is complete.
For a home you have just moved into, consider how many exterior locks need to work together and whether you have working keys for all of them. This guide explains whether to rekey locks after moving into a new home.
When a Rekey Will Not Solve the Lock Problem
Rekeying addresses which key works; it does not repair broken hardware. A key that repeatedly sticks, a cylinder that feels loose, or a bolt that fails to move calls for an inspection before anyone treats the job as a simple rekey.
Do not force a bent key or try to take the cylinder apart. Forcing it can leave the key stuck or make the lock harder to assess. Contact a locksmith when the lock will not operate reliably, a key has broken in it, or you cannot tell whether the problem comes from the lock or the door.
Our mobile locksmith comes to you. Before arranging work, describe what the key does and whether the lock works with the door open; that helps focus the inspection on the right part of the problem.
Prepare the Locks and Keys You Want Rekeyed
A short inventory helps you avoid leaving an exterior lock out of the work. Gather the details, but leave disassembly and lock changes to the locksmith.
- Identify each lock — List the door and whether it has a deadbolt, a doorknob lock, or both. If multiple locks should use the same key, say so before work begins.
- Set aside working keys — Bring together the keys you have and note which ones operate which locks. Tell the locksmith if a key is missing or a lock has no working key.
- Point out damage or sticking — Show any key that catches, lock that binds, or hardware that appears loose. These details matter because a worn or damaged lock may need repair or replacement instead of rekeying.
- Confirm the scope — Ask which locks can be rekeyed and which key will operate each one afterward. For advice about how much it costs to rekey a house in South Florida, see our separate cost guide.
Need help now? (754) 342-6282
Choose a Locksmith Who Can Explain the Lock Work
Ask the locksmith to identify which locks are suitable for rekeying and which need a different service. Before work starts, confirm the locks included and the intended key arrangement. You can ask any locksmith for proof of licensing and insurance; the Associated Locksmiths of America also offers information for consumers choosing a locksmith.
Locksmith South Florida is licensed and insured, and our mobile locksmith serves Broward, Miami-Dade, and Palm Beach counties. To arrange a visit, contact us and describe the lock, the key problem, and the result you want.
Frequently asked questions
Can every door lock be rekeyed?
Not every lock is suitable for rekeying, and the lock’s condition matters too. A locksmith needs to identify the lock and check its cylinder before confirming whether rekeying or replacement fits.
Will rekeying make my old keys stop working?
Yes, rekeying changes the lock’s keying so the old keys no longer operate that lock. Ask the locksmith to identify which locks were rekeyed and test each one with the new key afterward.
Should I rekey a lock that sticks?
Not automatically. A sticking key can point to wear or another lock problem, and rekeying does not repair damaged hardware; have the lock checked before choosing the service.
How much does it cost to rekey a house?
The total depends on the locks and the work required, so the lockout prices listed elsewhere do not establish a rekeying price. See our South Florida house rekey cost guide for details.
Have a lock that needs attention?
Call (754) 342-6282 to describe the lock and arrange mobile locksmith service.