Skip to content
Open 24/7 Fort Lauderdale & nearby
Locksmith South Florida logo Español (754) 342-6282

Rekey Between Tenants: A Guide for South Florida Landlords

Rekey between tenants to make the old keys stop operating the locks, as long as the existing hardware is in good condition. Call a mobile locksmith to check the doors, rekey compatible locks, and identify any hardware that needs replacement.

Edge of a white door with a brass mortise lock, latch and round knobs

Need help now? (754) 342-6282

Why Rekey Between Tenants Before the Next Move-In?

Rekeying changes the lock cylinder so the old key no longer operates it, while the existing lock hardware stays in place. It is a practical way to restore key control after a tenant leaves, especially when you cannot account for every copy of the previous key.

Plan to include every entry that uses a key: the front and back doors, a side entrance, and any other exterior door that gives access to the rental. A tenant may have shared a copy with someone else, and keys can also be misplaced during a move. Rekeying the main entrance but overlooking another keyed door leaves an old key useful at that second entry.

This work is different from changing a lock. A locksmith checks whether the existing cylinder is suitable, then resets it for a new key. See our lock rekeying service for details on getting the rental’s locks serviced.

Should You Rekey or Replace the Rental’s Locks?

Choose based on the condition and compatibility of the hardware, not only on the tenant change. A locksmith can inspect the lock and tell you whether it can be rekeyed or needs replacement.

Rekey sound, working locks

This option keeps the existing hardware but changes which key operates it. It fits a lock that works smoothly and is in suitable condition for rekeying.

Replace damaged or unreliable locks

Replacement is the better route when a lock is damaged, worn, or otherwise not suitable to rekey. Ask the locksmith to check the door and hardware together so a replacement can operate correctly in the opening.

Check keypad or electronic locks separately

A keypad lock may use both a physical key and stored access codes. Review the maker’s instructions for changing codes, and ask the locksmith whether the physical cylinder also needs rekeying. For Schlage products, use Schlage’s support resources for model-specific guidance.

Which Rental Doors and Keys Belong on Your Turnover List?

Make a complete list before arranging the work. The goal is to account for every keyed entrance and identify anything that needs separate attention.

Need help now? (754) 342-6282

How to Prepare for a Rental Rekey, Step by Step

These steps help you define the work and check the result without taking apart a lock yourself. Leave cylinder removal and rekeying to a locksmith.

  1. Confirm you can authorize the work — Make sure you have authority to arrange service for the rental and its locks. Keep any access or property-management instructions available for the appointment.
  2. List every keyed entry — Write down each door and identify the lock on it. Compare the list with the property layout so a side or rear entrance does not get missed.
  3. Test each lock normally — Use the current key and check whether the lock turns and the door latches without unusual effort. Note a sticking key, loose hardware, or a door that needs adjustment rather than forcing it.
  4. Gather returned keys — Collect keys from the departing tenant and label them by door if you know which one each fits. Treat missing copies as possible; collecting keys alone does not invalidate them.
  5. Identify special hardware — Point out keypad locks, unusual cylinders, or doors with more than one lock. Tell the locksmith which doors share a key, if known, so the hardware can be checked as a set.
  6. Decide whether a lock needs more than rekeying — Flag locks that are damaged, unreliable, or difficult to operate. Ask the locksmith to inspect them and determine whether rekeying is appropriate or replacement is needed.
  7. Arrange the rekey service — Give the locksmith the door list and describe any problems you noticed. We provide mobile lock rekeying in South Florida, including Broward, Miami-Dade, and Palm Beach counties.
  8. Check every door with the new key — Before the next tenant takes possession, test each serviced lock with its new key and confirm the door latches. Keep the new keys labeled and controlled, and ask the locksmith to address any lock that does not work as expected.

What to Do When a Rental Lock Will Not Rekey Cleanly

A stiff key, a lock that fails to turn, or a door that will not latch can point to a problem beyond key control. Do not force the key or keep testing a lock that binds; that can worsen the problem or leave the door difficult to secure.

Tell the locksmith which key you tried, which door is affected, and what happened when you operated it normally. The locksmith can inspect the cylinder and door hardware, then determine whether rekeying, repair, or replacement is the appropriate next step.

If the new key works in some serviced doors but not another, check that you are using the key assigned to that lock and contact the locksmith who performed the work. Avoid making changes to the lock before the issue is checked.

What Affects the Cost to Rekey a Rental?

The cost to rekey depends on the locks involved and how many cylinders need service. The condition and type of hardware also matter: a damaged or incompatible lock may need a different service than a working lock that can be rekeyed.

Before work begins, give the locksmith the number of keyed doors and describe any sticking or damaged locks. Ask what the quoted work includes and whether any lock needs replacement rather than rekeying. For a separate cost discussion, see how much it costs to rekey a house in South Florida.

Lockout prices are not the same as rekeying prices, so do not use a lockout starting price to estimate a turnover rekey. For help choosing a locksmith, the Associated Locksmiths of America offers consumer information; you can also ask a locksmith for proof of the business credentials they state.

Need help now? (754) 342-6282

How to Keep the New Rental Keys Under Control

Once the locks are serviced, keep the new keys separate from old or unmarked keys and record which doors they operate. Give keys only to people who need access, and track copies issued and returned as part of your turnover records.

If several doors use different keys, label them in a way that identifies the door without revealing the rental address if the set is lost. For keypad locks, handle access codes separately from physical keys and follow the manufacturer’s instructions for changing them.

A rekey does not repair a door that fails to close or a lock that does not operate reliably. Treat those issues as maintenance items before the next tenant moves in, and revisit the choice between rekeying and replacement with our guide to whether to rekey or replace your locks.

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to rekey a rental property?

The price depends on the number and type of locks and their condition. Ask for a quote based on the doors and hardware involved; a lockout price does not tell you the cost of a rekey.

Can one new key work for every lock in the rental?

That depends on whether the locks are compatible and can be set to work with the same key. Have the locksmith check each cylinder rather than assuming the doors can all use one key.

Do I need to rekey if the departing tenant returned every key?

Returned keys do not show whether additional copies exist or were shared. Rekeying changes which key operates the lock, so the old keys no longer provide access to a successfully rekeyed cylinder.

What should I do if a new key sticks after rekeying?

Stop forcing it and note which door and key are affected. Contact the locksmith who serviced the lock so they can check the cylinder and door operation.

Get the Rental Ready for Its Next Tenant

Share the doors and lock issues you have found, and we can arrange mobile lock rekeying.

More helpful guides

(754) 342-6282 Get a quote